donbot Posted October 13, 2011 Posted October 13, 2011 and what is this list for?Same list, but sorted alphabetically. Jennka suggested we have it there so it's easier to find people in the list. Don't really need it for only 30 though <_< Terese Pagh Teglgaard [5]Jarah Mariano [5] Quote
Tran Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Terese Pagh Teglgaard [6]Jarah Mariano [5] Quote
arielle Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Terese Pagh Teglgaard [6]Jarah Mariano [6] Quote
eddiwouldgo Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Terese Pagh Teglgaard [6]Jarah Mariano [7] Quote
'susan' Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Terese Pagh Teglgaard [6]Jarah Mariano [8] Quote
Jennka Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Uff, okay. We can leave it like this. No retrospective in rounds, only the models list and chart (I would leave only the first 10, if you ask me). I´m still gonna make the evidence in my excell of the rounds retrospective, though. Terese Pagh Teglgaard [6]Jarah Mariano [9] Quote
Jennka Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 I meant this:MODELS WHO CANNOT BE PICKED THIS ROUNDUntil 30 rounds have cycledDioni Tabbers ( On cycle #1)Siri TollerødRomee StrijdAlena SavostikovaFabiana TambosiAmanda StreichSara SampaioAnais MaliMilou SluisXenia Deli•Martina Sukupova (On cycle #11)Viktoria HalenarovaHanna VerheesNastassia LindesMonika JagaciakKarlie KlossMarina LaswickMarte MeiBeegee MargenyteChristy Turlington (On cycle #20)•Claudia GuarnieriAshley PerichKendell TobinMilly SimmondsMarija VujovicAlyssah AliLorraine Van WykAnna DruzyakaAnka KapusnakovaGabrielle Pollock (On cycle #30)Model chart (so far!):1. Marina Laswick (21 wins)2. Catrinel Menghia (12 wins)3. Petra Nemcova (10 wins)Others:Nina Agdal (9 wins)Alejandra Alonso (7 wins)Ariadne Artiles (7 wins)Terese Pagh Teglgaard (6 wins so far)Valentina Zelyaeva (6 wins)Nicole Trunfio (6 wins)Gemma Ward (6 wins)So a model has to achieve at least 6 wins to be in the list. AND if someone nominates e.g. Marina Laswick again, the previous number of wins is deleted and valid are only her newly achieved wins. This will keep the fresh winner all the time. Quote
Michael* Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Terese Pagh Teglgaard [7]Jarah Mariano [9] Quote
Mickiala Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Terese Pagh Teglgaard [7] Jarah Mariano [10] No clue how this is working now, someone else take over Quote
Theron Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 So a model has to achieve at least 6 wins to be in the list. AND if someone nominates e.g. Marina Laswick again, the previous number of wins is deleted and valid are only her newly achieved wins. This will keep the fresh winner all the time. So if I don't like Marina Laswick I just nominate her again and she disappears... That's just an example of what could happen to any model with this rule. <_< I would add them instead, though in that case continuing the contest with different new rules would not be fair, cause it is impossible that Marina Laswick got 21 wins in a row with these new rules, and it's a bit of a mess mixing previous results with previous rules with the future ones. Quote
axrw Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 I think it would be interesting to have a consecutive win and total win list, so we're not losing the data when someone got renominated. That said, the book keeping requirements for all this seems a bit ridiculous to expect someone to do. I'm in agreement with Theron about the mixing of the results. When you think about it with the new rules the spirit of this competition is really a bit different than the previous. A new start seems fitting with a new thread where the standings could be updated on the first post periodically. Either way though, I'm happy to see competition getting a breath of fresh air. Quote
siniko Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 how about a new thread is started with the rules clearly defined and we continue from there Quote
ILUVAdrianaLima Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Sounds like a whole new start on a new thread is needed from what i keep reading.For the most part the premises of this comp will stay the same. With that said i say lets start this new comp already with the given below agreed upon. 1. Once a model is chosen she may not appear again until 30 rounds have cycled.2. Model chart will stay the same and keep track of a models current win streak.3. I retract a past statement. A retrospective list will and should be included but of only the last 30 rounds.So how about it all lets start? Quote
Theron Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 I think it would be interesting to have a consecutive win and total win list, so we're not losing the data when someone got renominated. That said, the book keeping requirements for all this seems a bit ridiculous to expect someone to do.Right. That could be done listing them with something like this:Candice Boucher = 12 + 5 + 1 = 18 winsOlga Kurylenko = 1 + 16 = 17 winsand so on...In fact 2 lists could be done, one with total wins and another one with most consecutive wins.Olga Kurylenko = 16 consecutive winsCandice Boucher = 12 consecutive winsand so on...BTW, all these new rules could be applied to the actresses thread as it is now, cause we haven't done many rounds there, maybe not the 30 or 50 required to renominate somebody. Quote
ILUVAdrianaLima Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Well the thing here is, i want to stick with the original game play as much as possible. My whole intention in the begging was just to re-work the rule about not choosing a model ever again but allowing those models to be available after 30 round cycles. I really loved the original set up but i just wanted to make sure the comp kept going and wouldn't stall due to a lack of contestants. I re-adjusted the chart below to integrate the 2 lists mentioned above in one list. Of course we would only take into account the win streak in terms of 1st, 2nd, 3rd place and so on, hope it looks okay. So in essence this is how the set up will look like below. BELOW IS JUST AN EXAMPLE. MODELS WHO CANNOT BE PICKED THIS ROUND Until 30 rounds have cycled Dioni Tabbers ( On cycle #1) Siri Tollerød Romee Strijd Alena Savostikova Fabiana Tambosi Amanda Streich Sara Sampaio Anais Mali Milou Sluis Xenia Deli • Martina Sukupova (On cycle #11) Viktoria Halenarova Hanna Verhees Nastassia Lindes Monika Jagaciak Karlie Kloss Marina Laswick Marte Mei Beegee Margenyte Christy Turlington (On cycle #20) • Claudia Guarnieri Ashley Perich Kendell Tobin Milly Simmonds Marija Vujovic Alyssah Ali Lorraine Van Wyk Anna Druzyaka Anka Kapusnakova Gabrielle Pollock (On cycle #30) Model chart (so far!): Total wins / Model Name / Win Streak (25) Marina Laswick (21) (18) Catrinel Menghia (12) (15) Petra Nemcova (10) (15) Nina Agdal (9 wins) (7) Alejandra Alonso (7) (7) Ariadne Artiles (7) (8) Terese Pagh Teglgaard (6) (6) Valentina Zelyaeva (6) (6) Nicole Trunfio (6 ) (6) Gemma Ward (6 ) (7) Izabel Goulart (5) (5) Magdalena Frackowiak (4) (4) Emanuela De Paula (4) (4) Marloes Horst (4) (6) Jenna Pietersen (4) (6) Candice Swanepoel (4) (5) Hilary Rhoda (4) (4) Diana Morales (4) (4) Sara Sampaio (4) (5) Xenia Deli (5) (3) Edita Vilkeviciute (3) (4) Jessica Stam (3) (5) Daniela Cosio (3) (3) Miranda Kerr (3) (3) Barbara Herrera (3) (3) Zuzana Gregorova (3) (5) Lana Zakocela (3) (2) Yesica Toscanini (2) (2) Florencia Salvioni (2) (2) Marisa Miller (2) (2) Laetitia Casta (2) (2) Candice Boucher (2) (2) Natalia Vodianova (2) (2) Tori Praver (2) (2) Gio Ott (2) Retrospective (Last 30 Rounds): Marina Laswick VZ Choice Gray Marina Laswick VZ Alisa Basyuk Marina Laswick VZ Joanna Stubbs Marina Laswick VZ Alice Navaratova Marina Laswick VZ Diana Moldovan Marina Laswick VZ Gabrielle Pollock Marina Laswick VZ Anka Kapusnakova Marina Laswick VZ Anna Druzyaka Marina Laswick VZ Lorraine Van Wyk Marina Laswick VZ Alyssah Ali Marina Laswick VZ Marija Vujovic Marina Laswick VZ Milly Simmonds Marina Laswick VZ Kendell Tobin Marina Laswick VZ Ashley Perich Marina Laswick VZ Claudia Guarnieri Marina Laswick VZ Christy Turlington Marina Laswick VZ Beegee Margenyte Marina Laswick VZ Marte Mei Marina Laswick VZ Monika Jagaciak Monika Jagaciak VZ Karlie Kloss Monika Jagaciak VZ Xenia Deli Xenia Deli VZ Nastassia Lindes Xenia Deli VZ Hanna Verhees Xenia Deli VZ Viktoria Halenarova Xenia Deli VZ Martina Sukupova Xenia Deli VZ Sara Sampaio Sara Sampaio VZ Milou Sluis Sara Sampaio VZ Anais Mali Sara Sampaio VZ Amanda Streich Amanda Streich VZ Terese Pagh Teglgaard Quote
Theron Posted October 14, 2011 Posted October 14, 2011 Well the thing here is, i want to stick with the original game play as much as possible. My whole intention in the begging was just to re-work the rule about not choosing a model ever again but allowing those model to be available after 30 round cycles.I really loved the original set up but i just wanted to make sure the comp kept going and wouldn't stall due to a lack of contestants. So your second list or the one we had before that kept track of the model win streaks is all that i think we should have, but i truly value your input. Well, both lists are complementary, one doesn't discard the other, and both give interesting information. And I insist, 30 rounds are too few, I initially said 50, but I believe 100 would keep the competition as similar as possible to what it was before. Just take a look at the actresses list where we have around 30 rounds so far, and now imagine you could begin to renominate everybody when many actresses (most of them) still have not appeared. I think the wait should be longer. 1. Kristen Stewart VZ Emma Stone 2. Emma Stone VZ Keira Knightley 3. Keira Knightley VZ Eva Mendes 4. Keira Knightley VZ Mia Wasikowska 5. Keira Knightley VZ Rachel McAdams 6. Keira Knightley VZ Penelope Cruz 7. Keira Knightley VZ Emma Watson 8. Keira Knightley VZ Monica Bellucci 9. Keira Knightley VZ Scarlett Johansson 10. Keira Knightley VZ Halle Berry 11. Keira Knightley VZ Olivia Wilde 12. Keira Knightley VZ Sophie Marceau 13. Keira Knightley VZ Amanda Seyfried 14. Keira Knightley VZ Amber Heard 15. Keira Knightley VZ Blake Lively 16. Keira Knightley VZ Mila Kunis 17. Keira Knightley VZ Nicole Kidman 18. Keira Knightley VZ Kate Beckinsale 19. Kate Beckinsale VZ Kelly Brook 20. Kate Beckinsale VZ Kate Winslet 21. Kate Beckinsale VZ Jennifer Aniston 22. Kate Beckinsale VZ Salma Hayek 23. Kate Beckinsale VZ Summer Glau 24. Kate Beckinsale VZ Katie Holmes 25. Kate Beckinsale VZ Jessica Biel 26. Kate Beckinsale VZ Evangeline Lilly 27. Kate Beckinsale VZ Milla Jovovich Quote
ILUVAdrianaLima Posted October 15, 2011 Posted October 15, 2011 While they do both complement each other well, i wanted to keep it as simple and streamlined as possible, thus why an additional list would defeat the purpose here, but trust me i like the idea, you are the king of comps in my opinion after-all.Oh, and 30 seems perfect so far vs 50, or 100, and here is why. We obviously have to keep a list of every model that has been choose up to 30, 50, 100 round cycles. And most people will not bother looking at a huge list of contestants they can't choose and just move away from this comp due to the increase hassle of looking to see whether there model is in that list or not. Why i kept it at 30, list isn't to short or to long but just right i think. Quote
ILUVAdrianaLima Posted October 15, 2011 Posted October 15, 2011 Okay after even more reading and great ideas i have adjusted the chart above to represent all the new ideas and fixes to any potential issues.One last note on the comp. Issue regarding someone being re-entered into the comp multiple times after the 30 round cycle rule. Lets say Petra Nemcova enters for the first time and manages a 10 win streak. After being defeated the 11th round she would obviously not be a contender until 30 rounds have passed. And lets say on her next time up she manages a 7 win streak, the streak that will be recorded is 10, not 7. That's why a additional column for wins was added to address this issue. That way we now have streaks and overall wins to reference from for each model that has been archived. Quote
Clauds Posted October 15, 2011 Posted October 15, 2011 Maybe im just dumb but i don't understand a shit ... Theron can i get an explanation in spanish please? Quote
Theron Posted October 15, 2011 Posted October 15, 2011 Maybe im just dumb but i don't understand a shit ... Theron can i get an explanation in spanish please? Todo sigue igual sólo que ahora cuando han pasado 30 rondas se pueden repetir las modelos, o lo que es lo mismo, las únicas que no se pueden escoger son las 30 últimas. Y en las tablas el número de la izquierda indicará las victorias totales de cada una, y el de la derecha el mayor número de victorias consecutivas. (I don't translate it cause I have just said what has been said in English several times in this page) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.