Trends Posted June 27, 2013 Posted June 27, 2013 With 30-21 coming up, I wonder is this where models like Elsa Benitez, Carol Alt, Ana BB, Rebecca Romijn, and Molly Sims will be placed at?I at least got Elsa and Ana's placement right and I'm glad I got the rest of them wrong. Stacey Williams might make the list. All of the post-Beyonce SI covergirls and Anne V are still in it. Even with the recentism charges, I don't think all six of them will be in the Top 10. I think 3 or 4 of the will make the Top 10.
Clauds Posted June 27, 2013 Posted June 27, 2013 What the fuck at Marisa being 13? Seriously? Even Bar made the Top 10 and Marisa didn't? PffffKate for #1 y'all!
Stormbringer Posted June 27, 2013 Posted June 27, 2013 ^ That wouldn't surprise me at all at this point. And Elle at #7 or something
Clauds Posted June 27, 2013 Posted June 27, 2013 The list is such a joke. Like seriously love love love Bar & especially love Brooklyn Decker, but they are by no means more significant in terms of SI than Marisa Miller she covered the magazine first, she did it for more years and she had a bigger impact IMO, and Anne holds the record for the most consecutive times in the magazine (well technically she won't until February but we all know she'll be there already) now so I do think she deserves to be a little higher too, not Top 10 but at least at 15.
Trends Posted June 28, 2013 Posted June 28, 2013 Elle #1Kathy #2Kate#3They got the #1 right but the overall top 10 list is messed up.
ve.ro.nika Posted June 28, 2013 Posted June 28, 2013 I have nothing against Brooklyn but I would replace her with Marisa or Irina. On the other hand, neither of them is in movies so it makes publicity for both Brooklyn and SI. I think it would be amazing if Diane Smith made her own list.
Clauds Posted June 28, 2013 Posted June 28, 2013 Yeah i don't think Tyra should be out of the Top 3 and i also don't think Bar should be higher than Paulina.At least Brooklyn ranked well so yay for that I guess
Clauds Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 So this is the Top 10 in SwimDaily1. Elle MacPherson2. Kathy Ireland3. Kate Upton4. Tyra Banks5. Heidi Klum6. Cheryl Tiegs7. Brooklyn Decker8. Christie Brinkley 9. Bar Refaeli 10. Paulina PorizkovaHowever, I noticed in the video names that the Top 10 in their youtube channel is not quite the same after #4 http://www.youtube.c...swimsuit/videos1. Elle MacPherson2. Kathy Ireland3. Kate Upton4. Tyra Banks5. Brooklyn Decker6. Cheryl Tiegs7. Bar Refaeli8. Heidi Klum9. Christie Brinkley10. Paulina PorizkovaI particularly like the order from youtube better
Stormbringer Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 I like the first top ten better... because Heidi is ranked higher Well, the top ten is quite okay, but the list as a whole is a bit "curious" in my opinion.
ILUVAdrianaLima Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 ^ Top 10 (either list) actually sits well with me from what I know of past SI cover model history. LoL, but the rest seemed more a jumbled random mess then anything else.
Clauds Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 I like the Top 10 okay, however i would kick Bar out and put Marisa Miller in. Other than that it's okay. I like the second list better for obvious reasons but everyone knows I'm biased with Brooklyn and SI The other 40 are just a joke though. I'm just surprised they included Hilary Rhoda when he pretty much trashed the magazine
ve.ro.nika Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 The other 40 are just a joke though. I'm just surprised they included Hilary Rhoda when he pretty much trashed the magazine
Cult Icon Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 This list is by no means a 'historical' listing, that deems the impact of these models based on release era Where is the criteria for their selection? (a link would suffice...) This list is also clearly over-weighted by recent models. Also, the quality of the photography declined as the magazine aged, so you have a mixture of real photography and the heavily Photoshopped kind squeezed together. The criteria certainly does not put much weight in the enduring quality of the photographs at all, as if that was the case...then the supermodels would be float to the top and everybody else to the bottom... If judging by the parameters of the actual pictures and the beauty of the women in there...I think that the list looks like a mess. There are first class supermodels and top models mixed with third tier models that like G. Morton, Julie Henderson, and Jessica Gomes.
jj3 Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 MJ DAY said on her twitter :"Who thinks we should hold a fan vote for 50 greatest!!!? I do!!! "https://twitter.com/MJ_Day/status/350744851970666498I think indeed this would be a very good thing ! It would be just normal ...
ve.ro.nika Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 Since they manipulated votes in rookie of the year I believe they will manipulate votes in this poll as well. But it is a good idea anyway.
Cult Icon Posted June 29, 2013 Posted June 29, 2013 Veronika,Hilary, in an interview, criticized the quality of the magazine. She said that it was declining and implied that it was damaging to 'her brand'.What did she say?
Begonia Posted June 30, 2013 Posted June 30, 2013 Josie so sexy would have luv 2 see her in the list What about Michelle Vawer, Esti Ginzburg, Julie Ordon & Alyssa Miller?
Recommended Posts