Who has been the greatest live act ever?

29 replies · 7464 views

Greenpea's avatar
Greenpea
Posts: 27
#1

Who has been the greatest live act ever?

The best band or act you've ever seen?

The Stones, U2, Bruce Springsteen, Madonna, Queen, Pink Floyd, The Who, Bowie, Dylan, Kiss, Nirvana or someone else?

This Day in Music have just started a poll to find out. If you fancy voting for who you think should win go to http://www.thisdayinmusic.com

You can vote for any act, just go to 'other' on the list.

t
thats haute
Posts: 610
#2

Queen perhaps

or Radiohead

or The Hives

never seen them live though

Qball's avatar
Qball
Posts: 16908
#3

Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple and Queen.

lilsurprises's avatar
lilsurprises
Posts: 44
#4

I think Prince's performance is outstanding!!!!!!! What that man can do with a guitar is unbelievable! (and typically I am a 1970s rock 'n roll type of girl, so...there you have it) lol

Get your sexy on!'s avatar
Get your sexy on!
Posts: 3337
#5
madgebj6.jpg

:hell yea!:

nuff said!

Crackberry's avatar
Crackberry
Posts: 598
#6

muse

Keeper of the Crayons's avatar
Keeper of the Crayons
Posts: 26423
#7

Daft Punk

Bloc Party

t
thats haute
Posts: 610
#8

mmmm.... bloc party live isn't exactly my favorite

most of the time i'm disappointed when i hear them

Keeper of the Crayons's avatar
Keeper of the Crayons
Posts: 26423
#9

really? why is that?

they were down here last week and I went to see them. they were amazing imho :hell yea!:

I see the lies in your eyes and yet I love you just the same's avatar
I see the lies in your eyes and yet I love you just the same
Posts: 25928
#10

If we're purely talking about the live act and performance, than for me it's easily Beck and the Roots.

Radiohead is a great band, I've attended two great live shows of them, but they don't stand out because of their live show. They just do an adequate job of bringing the magic from the album to the stage. Which is commendable in itself. I recently saw MGMT and they are crap live. As much as I love them on their album.

U2 are great, but they are also super-professional, which means that some of the early magic is gone. My two uncles did see them in the early 80s (their first gigs on the continent were in Belgium) and said they were amazing. They created an almost sacred atmosphere. But no band can keep that alive for close to three decades, especially not if you become "the biggest band in the world" along the way.

officially irrelevant's avatar
officially irrelevant
Posts: 11167
#11

I wanna say The Who, but i wouldnt know

I LIKE TO FORK MYSELF: 1989-2009's avatar
I LIKE TO FORK MYSELF: 1989-2009
Posts: 4169
#12

my lifespan is too short lived to tell...

The Ting Tings are shitty on the radio... but damn! they're amazing live!!!

CSS is amazing!!!

Feist surprisingly rocks out amazing solos!

Rilo Kiley is great with ghetto-tech props!

Nightlife's avatar
Nightlife
Posts: 4305
#13

The Best concert i went to was prince(21 nights in london)...he was just sensational!!! As lilsurprises says what the man can do with a gutar is jaw dropping Never seen anything quite like that...Other faves are U2(vertigo tour) A very polished perfomance with a great atmosphere. Altho bono did go on a bit with his speaches about the 3rd world Linkin Park(minuites to midnight) was insane..and the last two songs(place for your head and one step closer) was just amazing and i couldn't help myself but get out of my seat Justin Timberlake(futurelovesex tour) was a great concert too(Timberland was there and he did a 45mins set in the middle..just fantastic Eric Clapton was a legend also...been quite lucky i guess

*Bronx_Bomber*'s avatar
*Bronx_Bomber*
Posts: 84622
#14

For me-Depeche Mode.With Morrissey a very close second.

I never understood the frequency uh huh's avatar
I never understood the frequency uh huh
Posts: 15189
#15

I've been lucky enough to have seen many a great gig, but my all-time favourite would have to be The White Stripes. If the chance to see them comes along again, take my advice and plunge in with both feet. Having been to my first Morrissey gig in February, I wholeheartedly agree that he's amazing too. And although they're getting increasingly populist these days, third place goes to Kings of Leon circa 'Aha Shake Heartbreak'.

Of the bands I'd most like to have seen in their prime, probably The Who and Nirvana.

Taylor Swift Fearless Speak Now RED 1989  REPUTATION's avatar
Taylor Swift Fearless Speak Now RED 1989 REPUTATION
Posts: 321
#16

DEEP PURPLE at Beatyy Park in Perth may 1971 if my memory serves me correct.

An awesome concert and hasnt been bettered in all those years.

(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻'s avatar
(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
Posts: 22337
#17

Robert Cray was simply amazing when i saw him with Clapton.

Cray was just outstanding, i couldn't believe how great he sounded. No special effects or anything, just cray with his band, and amazing music.

Rush (my favorite band) put on 2 good shows when i went to see them aswell

But just from the music standpoint by far Robert Cray.

R
Randy The Ram
Posts: 1096
#18

KISS

Bruce Springsteen

AC/DC

Motorhead

Deep Purple

The Black Crowes

Bob Seger

(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻'s avatar
(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
Posts: 22337
#19

Kiss truly was/is a live band. Their studio albums are alright, but the live albums are just the best. I wish i could've seen them live when they were huge!

penny.lane's avatar
penny.lane
Posts: 5471
#20

i don't know if he can count since he doesn't actually sing...lol

but Armin van Buuren was AMAZING live

Page of 2