All-Time BEST VS Commercial Competition - RESULTS
1144 replies · 118239 views
ROUND 1
Victoria's Secret "Dream Angels Desire" (2000)
Mood/Theme (The feeling, tone and message the commercial is conveying---How good of a job did the commercial achieve this?)
Music (How appropriate & fitting was the music? How much did you like the music?)
Visual Elements (Camera angles & shots, scenes, editing, transitions, effects, filters, etc.---How much did you like the visual elements?)
Effectiveness (How well did the commercial promote the featured product(s)? Did the commercial persuade you to want to purchase the product(s)? Did the voice-over or lack of it help?)
Likability (Overall how much did you like the commercial?)
Copy & Paste the following onto a new post to rate:
Mood/Theme
Music
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability
Mood/Theme 4
Music 3
Visual Elements 3
Effectiveness 4
Likability 4
Mood/Theme 4
Music 2.5 - I'll excuse it a little bit because it was the 90's
Visual Elements 3. 5
Effectiveness 3.5
Likability 3.5
Pink, could you post the year of the ads if you know it?
Mood/Theme - 3.5
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 4
Effectiveness - 4
Likability - 3.5
Pink, could you post the year of the ads if you know it?
yeah, that would be great
Mood/Theme - 4
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 4.5
Effectiveness - 4
Likability - 4
Mood/Theme - 3.5
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 4
Effectiveness - 1.5 (wants to sell lingerie but only shows 2 seconds of a bra, a quick flash of undies and lots of feathers and up close mouth shots lolol)
Likability - 3.5
Mood/Theme - 3.5
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 4
Effectiveness - 2.5
Likability - 4
Mood/Theme 4
Music 2.5
Visual Elements 3
Effectiveness 3.5
Likability 4
Mood/Theme 4
Music 2
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 3
Likability 4
Who's the model?
^ Daniela Pestova
Mood/Theme: 3.7
Music: 3
Visual Elements: 4.3
Effectiveness: 2.5
Likability: 4
^ Thanks for answering 
she looks beautiful!
How old is this commercial? Cause i never seen this and don't know the model at all
Like this comp more then the previous one, love the variation and it's nice you get to see totally new things like models and stuff 
well done Pinky 
Pink, could you post the year of the ads if you know it?
yeah, that would be great
+ 1
Old school VS 
Mood/Theme: 4
Music: 3
Visual Elements: 3
Effectiveness: 2
Likability: 4
Pink, could you post the year of the ads if you know it?
yeah, that would be great
+ 1
Most of the commercials don't indicate the year but I will post it for the ones that are available 
Pink, could you post the year of the ads if you know it?
yeah, that would be great
+ 1
Most of the commercials don't indicate the year but I will post it for the ones that are available
Thanks for the effort
Mood/Theme: 5
Music: 3
Visual Elements: 4
Effectiveness: 4
Likability: 4.5
FYI: I am pretty sure the commercial is from 2000
------------------------------------------------------------------
Victoria's Secret "Dream Angels Desire" (2000)
Mood/Theme - 4.5
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 3.5
Effectiveness - 2 (had no clue it was a lingerie commercial until the voiceover kicked in)
Likability - 3.5
Round #1 Score: Victoria's Secret "Dream Angels Desire"
70.46
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ROUND 2
Note: No need to vote on the music this round.
Victoria's Secret "Body By Victoria" (2004)
Please rated the commercial on a scale of 1-5 (5 being the "best" score) on each of the following 5 criteria:
Mood/Theme (The feeling, tone and message the commercial is conveying---How good of a job did the commercial achieve this?)
Music (How appropriate & fitting was the music? How much did you like the music?)
Visual Elements (Camera angles & shots, scenes, editing, transitions, effects, filters, etc.---How much did you like the visual elements?)
Effectiveness (How well did the commercial promote the featured product(s)? Did the commercial persuade you to want to purchase the product(s)? Did the voice-over or lack of it help?)
Likability (Overall how much did you like the commercial?)
Copy & Paste the following onto a new post to rate (no need to vote on music this round):
Mood/Theme
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability
Mood/Theme 2
Music 1
Visual Elements 1.5
Effectiveness 2.5
Likability 1
Mood/Theme: 2
Visual Elements: 4
Effectiveness: 3
Likability: 2.8