53 replies · 12003 views

SI Swimsuit Models
vs.
Coulda, Shoulda Been SI Swimsuit Models
Premise
To pin these two specific teams against each other to the death. The SI Model Team are the ones that made it to the magazine. The Team Coulda, Shoulda Been are the ones who may have been interviewed or not, but could be said to rival some that made it. This is NOT an all-time best list or my favorites list for either side. The competition is how one particular group does against the other.
Rules
1. Vote one time, making a top 21 with any of the 100 names listed. They do not have to be in order, but they can if that is easier for you. Whichever side you have more from will count as your vote for that team.
2. You can post pictures, gifs or videos to support your list if you want.
3. Don't use enormous pictures (unless attached) or slow gifs.
4. For the sake of competitiveness, the criteria is attractiveness (by your tastes and standards) in their prime or the time of your peak interest. This is so that everyone can be compared on the most equal plane possible. For example, if you liked her more before the nose job or boob job, judge based on before the nose job or boob job. If you liked them more before you heard them talk, judge based on before you heard them talk. If you liked them more at a certain age, time of the year, before they dated such and such, rate based on that and so on.
Other
1. The team that wins for the greater number of voters will be the overall winner.
2. The team with the highest percentage of names in the votes overall will win an award.
3. The top 5 most recurring names in votes will also win an award.
4. If anyone on the Coulda Been list was actually in the magazine, let me know so that they can be replaced.

Team SI Swimsuit
Team Coulda, Shoulda Been

I had 3 repeat names on both teams.
Need 3 replacements for both to get 100. Suggestions greatly appreciated. Preferably someone you like and think gives the teams a good chance against the other.

Team SI:
Olivia Culpo
Team Coulda, Shoulda Been:
Stephanie Rayner

Team SI:
Kate Bock
Jasmine Sanders

18 minutes ago, Matt! said:There's more
![]()
I almost chocked.
Updated
Now I just need 4 names for the second team to begin.

Team Coulda, Shoulda Been
Natalie Roser

1 hour ago, Joe > Average said:Team SI Swimsuit
Is it possible to replace Olivia Culpo with Kelly Gale?

So do I pick 21 models from each list or from one list? This will be so interesting!!!

31 minutes ago, bump said:So do I pick 21 models from each list or from one list? This will be so interesting!!!
You choose any 21 names from the 100 overall. Whichever side you have more names from will be the team you voted for. That will be one score, the team with the most names named will be another. The top 5-10 individual names will be acknowledged too.
List Updated/Finished

1 hour ago, Joe > Average said:
![]()
![]()
I almost chocked.
![]()
Updated
Now I just need 4 names for the second team to begin.
Team Coulda, Shoulda Been
Gillian Nation?

When would you like our lists?

So I have to make my own teams with how many models each?
Plus, I came late, but I would have nominated Clara Alonso for the Shoulda list.

i want Emily Deyt-Aysage and Colleen Cole for the shoulda list or i'll not play this 😞

why not doing a list with our nominations and not like this? or add more models, there are a lot of good ones not on the list..and some already on the list aren't really good as swimsuit models imo

Coulda, Shoulda Been
Bella Hadid
Sofia Jamora
Sui He
Cindy Mello
Bryana Holly
Edita Vilkeviciute
Team SI
Kelly Gale
Marisa Miller - Pretty sure she is already listed as Melissa Miller tho.
Let me know if you need more names
Hey, great idea!
So, do you need more nominations or should we just pick our 21 favorite?

@Prettyphile
I am ready for them.
@Clauds
Thanks, and I'll change that spelling.
@lostdiadem
You make a top 21 from any of the 100 names above. Whichever side you have more names from will be the side you voted for.
@peroxideblonde
Because I was just getting my feet wet and wanted to go with something that could be started up and ready to go quickly. The original title was "Part 1" but I took it off to see how this worked first. I wanted ratings too, but 1s and 2s have so much more power than 10s and 9s...
@Enrico_sw
It is ready to go. Just pick your 21 favorite of the 100 names.
All new nominations added. Both lists are complete. Voting is open.

Team SI Swimsuit
Bar Refaeli
Barbara Palvin
Brooklyn Decker
Emily DiDonato
Hannah Ferguson
Irina Shayk
Josephine Skriver
Josie Maran
Kate Upton
Lais Ribiero
Sara Sampaio
Team Coulda, Shoulda Been
Adriana Lima
Candice Swanepoel
Colleen Cole
Doutzen Kroes
Emily Deyt-Aysage
Gisele Bundchen
Kelly Gale
Miranda Kerr
Nicola Cavanis
Taylor Hill

Team SI Swimsuit
Team Coulda, Shoulda Been