Amy Winehouse vs Joss Stone

29 replies · 12453 views

Qball's avatar
Qball
Posts: 16908
#1

The divas of modern soul.

Who's your favorite of the two? Musically, that is. Please don't judge looks, beauty, sexiness etc. here. Music-wise only!

It's really close for me. I can't decide yet, although I think I'd give a slight edge to Joss. Or maybe... I don't know...

s669038.jpg s755447.jpg

Colossal's avatar
Colossal
Posts: 291
#2

I vote for Joss, she has more soul in her singing then Amy

Model Fetish's avatar
Model Fetish
Posts: 8892
#3

Joss!

Posts: 7079
#4

Amy

i
irenistiQ
Posts: 29414
#5

I voted for Joss Stone, simply beQause, (besides the faQt that i'm a fan ) i thinQ she has a powerful voice. she started to gain reQognition when she was 16 with her Soul Sessions album.. you can hear some growth in her voice.. even though she tries to change the direQtion of her sound, i liQe the Qomforting tonality in her voice..

Rogue's avatar
Rogue
Posts: 9460
#6

I'd have to listen to Joss first ... but i love Amy.

ve.ro.nika's avatar
ve.ro.nika
Posts: 6880
#7

AMY!

alisa's avatar
alisa
Posts: 4009
#8

amy may be a mess, but she is the best voice in past 10 yrs and even more

Rogue's avatar
Rogue
Posts: 9460
#9

Wooo .. I nulled my vote by accident. I just listened to Joss and she sounds too much like Amanda marshall (who makes me want to puke). So .... I love Amy lol.

Eden's avatar
Eden
Posts: 48
#10

I voted for Ami

I like Joss but I prefer Amy ^^

FRANCY ITALY's avatar
FRANCY ITALY
Posts: 18732
#11

i voted for amy..

The White Queen's avatar
The White Queen
Posts: 8648
#12

I love both, but I chose Amy.

Dark Lord's avatar
Dark Lord
Posts: 4628
#13

Although I'm not a big fan of Joss's pronunciation, I love her voice.

She's also good enough to jam with Herbie hancock and Les Paul.

Winehouse will never reach that status of musicianship.

Live Life; Live Free's avatar
Live Life; Live Free
Posts: 3956
#14

Joss Stone

watermelon's avatar
watermelon
Posts: 5563
#15

Amy

I never understood the frequency uh huh's avatar
I never understood the frequency uh huh
Posts: 15189
#16

Winehouse. Soul music should come from the soul, and Joss doesn't have one.

Crackberry's avatar
Crackberry
Posts: 598
#17

amy!

avatar by katchitup's avatar
avatar by katchitup
Posts: 12997
#18

Amy

A gifted faker...'s avatar
A gifted faker...
Posts: 3214
#19

Joss, by far. Love her

t
thats haute
Posts: 610
#20

I like them both, but i chose amy

Page of 2