Favourite Cover Versions
202 replies · 38857 views
Original - 0
Cover - 10
Cover 5
Black Eyed Peas: 0
Sounds even worse today than it did back then. Luckily, I can now look back on it and laugh.
Alanis Morissette: 6
Not a fan of Alanis by any stretch, but at least I now know she's not completely humourless (unless calling your album "Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie" counts as a joke). Perhaps I've misjudged her. 
Original x0
Cover x5
OG - 10
Cover - 0
OG - 5
Cover - 0
Original - 0
Cover - 8
Cover - 5
omg ive been forgetting to vote too in my fav competition!!!!
original-0
cover-3
sorry dont like it much!
PS: OOOOPS :lol:
2.5 each 
))
It was cool to listen to Alanis' version, completely different to BEP's but I don't like it at all :| I guess "My humps" should just be trashy the way it is 
Original 2
Cover 3
2.5 each 
^Thanks for joining in
omg ive been forgetting to vote too in my fav competition!!!!original-0
cover-3
sorry dont like it much!
anjelina, you forgot to distribute 5 points amongst the two 
Results
My Humps
[nominated by donbot]
Original version by Black Eyed Peas scored 1.7/10
Cover version by Alanis Morissette scored 5.6/10
Overall preference weighting goes to the COVER VERSION with 78.8% of the vote
12.5% of people preferred the original version
75% of people preferred the cover version
12.5% of people liked them equally
The Man Who Sold The World
[nominated by Michael*]
Original by David Bowie
Cover by Nirvana
HOW TO VOTE:
1. Rate the original version objectively out of 10
2. Rate the cover version objectively out of 10
3. Distribute 5 points amongst the two, based on how much you prefer one version over the other
Love both versions 
David Bowie: 9.5
Nirvana: 9.5
Original x 2.5
Cover x 2.5
God I love some Bowie, but...
David Bowie: 6
Nirvana: 9
Original x 1
Cover x 4
original: 7
cover:8
2.5 each
Absolutely love both. Slightly prefer the Nirvana version, but not enough to seperate them when distributing my five points.
David Bowie: 9
Nirvana: 9.5
Original x2.5
Cover x2.5
David Bowie: 4
Nirvana: 8
Original x 1
Cover x 4
Bowie is outstanding, but nirvana outdid him here
Original: 7.6
Cover: 8.4
Original: x1.5
Cover: x3.5
Original: 8
It's really a great song
Cover: 10
And that is an amazing cover
David Bowie: x2
Nirvana: x3
David Bowie: 7
Nirvana: 9.5
Original x 1
Cover x 4 - Kurt's voice is just too amazing & he was so cute in a "i look like a hobo.i need a wash" kinda way 
Results
The Man Who Sold The World
[nominated by Michael*]
Original version by David Bowie scored 7.3/10
Cover version by Nirvana scored 9/10
Overall preference weighting goes to the COVER VERSION with 65% of the vote
0% of people preferred the original version
62.5% of people preferred the cover version
37.5% of people liked them equally
Like a Prayer
[nominated by anjelina]
Original by Madonna
Cover by Mad'House
HOW TO VOTE:
1. Rate the original version objectively out of 10
2. Rate the cover version objectively out of 10
3. Distribute 5 points amongst the two, based on how much you prefer one version over the other
Original 7
Cover 6.5
Original x 3
Cover x2