Fragrance vs. Cosmetics Commercial Ultimate Battle...to the Death! ^_^

754 replies · 103572 views

Chocolate's avatar
Chocolate
Posts: 30686
#741

Rimmel 4

YSL 2.5

arielle's avatar
arielle
Posts: 1774
#742

Rimmel 3

YSL 4

Squeege Beckenheim's avatar
Squeege Beckenheim
Posts: 16299
#743

Rimmel: 3

YSL: 4

i'm big in japan's avatar
i'm big in japan
Posts: 11574
#744

Rimmel: 3.5

YSL: 4.5. Yeah Yeah Yeahs FTW

Bregje Heine(ke)n's avatar
Bregje Heine(ke)n
Posts: 30596
#745

Rimmel 3

Yves: 4,5

I never understood the frequency uh huh's avatar
I never understood the frequency uh huh
Posts: 15189
#746

Rimmel: 3

YSL: 4

Yeah Yeah Yeahs FTW

I never understood the frequency uh huh's avatar
I never understood the frequency uh huh
Posts: 15189
#747

Genuine bump.

♥ Doutzen ♥'s avatar
♥ Doutzen ♥
Posts: 4069
#748

Rimmel 4.5

Yves: 5

Bregje Heine(ke)n's avatar
Bregje Heine(ke)n
Posts: 30596
#749

is something happening with this thread? JOe?

Matching sets are for girls...with cooties!'s avatar
Matching sets are for girls...with cooties!
Posts: 17410
#750

Its definitely over . The only thing is that I did the scores by calculator and when I checked some I noticed they were wrong likely because of counting some twice or getting the number of votes wrong so I'll have to try excel once I reinstall office into this computer since I can no longer do personal things on the work computer and I haven't figured out how to do it on my phone either.

Matching sets are for girls...with cooties!'s avatar
Matching sets are for girls...with cooties!
Posts: 17410
#751

Results

  1. Fuel for Life Denim Collection (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 4.29
  2. Axe Exite (Nominated by Jennka) 4.163
  3. Guess Seductive Commercial (Nominated by Prettyphile) 4.045
  4. Emily - 4.09375
  5. Coco Rocha Yves Saint Laurent 3.884
  6. Avon - Eternal Magic - Ana Beatriz Barros (Nominated by sagitario) 3.8
  7. Calvin Klein Euphoria 3.72
  8. Maybelline New Dream Liquid Mousse (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 3.7
  9. The Axe Effect (Jennka) 3.67
  10. CKin2U 3.66 3.66
  11. Chanel Lipstick (Nominated by Squeege Beckinheim) 3.64
  12. Bruno Aveillan Eau De Rochas 3.61
  13. Revlon Grow Luscious (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 3.6
  14. Valentino Rock n' Rose Commercial 3.57
  15. Carolina Herrera (Nominated by SqueegeBechinheim) 3.566
  16. Perfume Pretty Barbie Commercial (Nominated by COP11) 3.48*
  17. Empirio Armani Diamonds (Nominated by Umbrella Beach) 3.464
  18. Fit Me Foundation Maybelline New York - 3.453
  19. L'Oreal Paris Infalliable Le Rouge Lip Color (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 3.38
  20. Mary Kay Commercial 3.38
  21. Flair by Revlon 3.38
  22. Timotei Commercial 3.321
  23. Maybelline Superstay Silky 3.27
  24. Tommy Girl Fragrance (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 3.23
  25. Perry Ellis for Women 3.2 3.2
  26. Rimmel London Max Volumeflash Mascara 3.2
  27. Kate - 3.19999
  28. Maybelline New York Color Sensational (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 3.16
  29. L'Oreal Sublime Bronze One Day 3.1428
  30. Scarlett Cacharell (Nominated by UmbreallaBeach) 3.11
  31. Ralph Lauren New Romance Perfume 3.1 3.1
  32. Christy Maybelline Great Lip 3.1 3.1
  33. Lancome Magnifique (Nominated by SqueegeBeckinheim) 3.036
  34. Coco Rocha Rimmel Nail Polish 3
  35. Givenchy Very Irresistible (Nominated by SqueegeBeckinheim) 2.977
  36. Lacoste Challenge (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.97 2.97
  37. Boss Orange Fragrance (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.97
  38. Charlize J'Adore Dior Fragrance 2.9375
  39. Tresor Midnight Rose (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.88
  40. Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Plush Eye Shadow (Nominated by sagitario) 2.88
  41. Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick (Nominated by sagitario) 2.88
  42. Gaultier Madame Perfume 2.88
  43. Escape Perfume for Women 2.88
  44. Avon Aney Emulsions (Nominated by Jennka) 2.87
  45. Lancome Miracle (Nominated by SqueegeBeckinheim) 2.83
  46. Mistine Lip Gloss 2.83
  47. Eternity Calvin Klein 2.81
  48. Revlon Flex Shampoo (COP11) 2.766
  49. Boss Orange Commercial 2.75
  50. CoverGirl Mascara (COP11) 2.6785
  51. Valentino Rock 'N Dreams (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.678
  52. Color Sensational High Shine Maybelline New York (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.66
  53. DOUTZEN KROES - Sublime Bronze One Day, L'Oreal (Nominated by sagitario) 2.66
  54. One Million & Lady Million By Paco Rabanne (Nominated by vanessaaa) 2.65
  55. Guerlain Inastand Magic 2.63
  56. Kenzo L'Eau Par Kenzo (Nominated by Squeege Beckinheim) 2.62
  57. Ralph Laren Romance 2.61
  58. Julie Ordon : Narta TV Commercial (Nominated by sagitario) 2.6
  59. Max Factor Lash Extension Mascara 2.571
  60. Pleasueres by Estee Lauder 2.57
  61. Max Factor Lash Extension Mascara 2.57
  62. Chloe - Love, Chloe (Nominated by SqueegeBeckinheim) 2.55
  63. Nivea Colour Nail 2.5416
  64. Covergirl Extract (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.5
  65. Miles Aldridge Bourjois Lipstick (Nominated by Squeege Beckenheim) 2.45
  66. Coco Chanel (Nominated by COP11) 2.416
  67. Sensi by Georgio Armani 2.416
  68. Revlon Unforgettable Perfume (Nominated by COP11) 2.409
  69. Revlon Just Bitten (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.4
  70. Lancose Touch of Pink (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.371
  71. Loreal Color Riche (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.36
  72. Ursula Mayes International Cosmetic (Nominated by Jennka) 2.357
  73. Dolce & Gabana Sicily 2.346
  74. Anuncio Spot Maybelline New York Colossal 2.33
  75. Lancose Touch of Pink (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.3
  76. Avon Clear Skin Professional (Nominated by Jennka) 2.29
  77. Mud Cosmetics (Nominated by Squeege Beckinheim) 2.25
  78. Max Factor Xperience 2.233
  79. Magie Noire (Nominated by SqueegeBeckinheim) 2.16
  80. Armani Code For Women 2.142
  81. Dorsey Green Cosmetics (Nominated by Jennka) 2.13
  82. L'Oréal Paris Glam Shine Reflexion Lip Gloss (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 2.04
  83. Cacharel: Amor Amor (Nominated by UmbreallaBeach) 2.03
  84. Isa Knox 2 (Nominated by Jennka) 2
  85. My Sweet 16 Cosmetics Commercial (Nominated by Jennka) 2
  86. Maybelline New York Watershine Elixer 1.96
  87. Cover Girl Ad (Nominated by COP11) 1.928
  88. Laneige Cosmetics (Nominated by Jennka) 1.9
  89. Chanel Les Fleurs D'été (Nominated by vanessaaa) 1.77
  90. Loreal Glam Shine (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach) 1.73
  91. Za Cosmetics (Nominated by Jennka) 1.7
  92. Mary Kay Fall in Love (Nominated by Jennka) 1.64
  93. Buxom Amplified Lash Mascara 1.47
  94. Someday Fragrance 1.27
  95. Chance by Chanel 0.973

Nor ordered and to be added...

Cheryl Cole Loreal - 1.91875

Raquel & Natasha Gucci Perfume Commercial - 1.6

Gisele - 3.5

Maybelline - 2.272

Chanel - 3.972

Lux - 1.88

Scarlett Johansson D&G The One - 2.5

Josie Maran Volum Express Maybelline New York - 2.6294

Angie Everhart Finesse Commercial - 1.08823

Gwen Stefani's Harajuku Lovers Fragrance - 1.4294

Veronica Varekova Nivea Mascara - 2

Ricci Ricci Perfume Commercial with Jessica Stam - 3.55

Taylor Swift CoverGirl NatureLuxe - 2.565

Kenzo Flower Fragrance - 2.825

Revlon Colorstay Lipstick - 3.1333

Victoria's Secret Fragrance - 3.22857 (to be altered as one voted before commercial was changed)

Midnight Poison by C Dior - 3.64

Drew Barrymore Covergirl Makeup Collection - 2.44375

Britney Spears Curious Perfume - 1.83125

Estee Lauder More than Mascara - 2

Valentino "Very Valentino" -2.525

Bianca - 2.6875

Garnier 1.9375

Prada 1.53125

Garnier - 1.66428

Revlon - 2.307

Cacharel - 2.8718

Shania Twain Revlon Colorstay Makeup - 2.142857

Britney Spears Fantasy Fragrance - 1.55

Aishwarya Rai Loreal - 2.0769

Juicy Couture Fragrance - 3.53571

Maybelline - 2.916

Miss Dior - 3.75

Julie Ordon Chanel - 3.0416

Evanteline Lily Cool Water Woman - 2.7083

Milla Jovovich L'Oreal Rouge Pulp - 2.708

Yves Saint Laurent YSL Paris Perfume - 1.508

Scarlett Johansson L'Oreal HIP - 1.683

Daria Werbowy Lancome Hypnose Senses - 3.425

Lancome Lipstick - 2.1125

Theorema Fendi - 2.46875

Color Rich L'Oreal - 2.6875

Stella McCartney - 2.9625

Anna Sui - 1.87

Forbidden Rose - 2.266

Dior Addict - 2.583

Chanel Number 5 - 3.875

Maybelline New York Fit Me Foundation - 3.0066

Inspire Perfume - 1.1066

L'Oreal Perfect Slim - 1.94

With Love Perfume - 1.613

Maybelline New York Fit Me Foundation - 3.0066

Inspire Perfume - 1.1066

Maybelline - 3.43

Givenchy - 2.66

Max Factor - 1.9

Versace - 2.125

Mary Kay Color 2.466

Miss Dior Cherie 2.966

Dior Addict Makeup 2.066

Bruno Avelain Lanvin Oxygene 3.513

Maybelline - 3.225

Guerlain - 3.34375

Maybelline - 2.59375

Dolce - 3.4375

Loreal = 1.86

Guerlain Mahora = 3.26

Maybelline Cat Eye Mascara = 2.43

Guilty Gucci = 3.86

Debon = 2.59375

VS Dream = 2.84

Maybelline Lash Stiletto = 4.25

Valentino V = 2.4

Loreal - 3.6

Thermasilk - 3.75

Nina Ricchi - 3.37857

Robert Cavali - 3.25

Versache Pur Femme - 2.115

Cover Girl Silk Foundation - 2.4615

Olay Body Wash - 2.964

Angel Thierry Mugler - 2.721

Mary Kay Commercial - 3.375

Guerlain Inastand Magic - 2.625

Maybelline New York Watershine Elixer - 1.958

Gaultier Madame Perfume - 2.875

Matching sets are for girls...with cooties!'s avatar
Matching sets are for girls...with cooties!
Posts: 17410
#752

That second list has to be ordered and added to the first, but that aside, the fragrances won .

A special thanks to the primary nominators Jennka, COP11, UmbrallaBeach and sagitario

Awards

Nominations (same as those mentioned above)

Perfect Attendance

Sagitario

Chocolate* - had to leave at one point, but voted when she was here

COP11 - sent her votes when she wasn't here

Most Objective

I'm proud of the group as a whole as I find the votes overall to be more objective than most comps.

Gold Male: Michael*

Gold Female: vanessaa

Silver Female: Jennka

Gold Overall: vanessaaa - when it came to giving low scores to things with people she loved and high scores to commercials with people she hated, she did it best .

Another special award coming .

Thanks to all the voters !

Bregje Heine(ke)n's avatar
Bregje Heine(ke)n
Posts: 30596
#753

Yay! I´m there! thank you Joe, this was a lot of fun to do

Chocolate's avatar
Chocolate
Posts: 30686
#754

Always great to be there!

Thanks Joe

sagitario's avatar
sagitario
Posts: 9765
#755

Thanks Joe

123…363738
Page of 38