All-Time BEST VS Commercial Competition - RESULTS
1144 replies · 118289 views
Mood/Theme 5
Music 3,5
Visual Elements 5
Effectiveness 4,5
Likability 5
Mood/Theme 3
Music 3
Visual Elements 2
Effectiveness 1
Likability 2 not enough Katsia
Pros: Very flattering shots of most of the girls, and who is the model opening the commercial? She's beautiful.
Cons: Unflattering shots of Rosie and I don't like Chanel Iman period.
Mood/Theme 5
Music 5
Visual Elements 5
Effectiveness 5
Likability 5
Mood/Theme 4
Music 3
Visual Elements 4 - I'm surprised Michael Bay doesn't try to sneak himself into a couple of those cuts.
Effectiveness 4
Likability 3.5
I want Edge Active Care back! :persuazn:
You mean the shaving cream?
Yes, it was amazing. Made my skin so smooth and soft. I was shocked they would discontinue such an effective product. 
Pros: Very flattering shots of most of the girls, and who is the model opening the commercial? She's beautiful.Cons: Unflattering shots of Rosie and I don't like Chanel Iman period.
Katsia Zingarevich / Damankova
I always liked this commercial. All the girls looked good. Even I hate Chanel and she didn't look bad.
All 4's for me.
Mood/Theme 4.5
Music 3
Visual Elements 4.5
Effectiveness 4.5
Likability 4.5
Mood/Theme 4.5
Music 3
Visual Elements 4.5
Effectiveness 4.5
Likability 4.5
+1
Mood/Theme 4
Music 2
Visual Elements 5
Effectiveness 3
Likability 5
Mood/Theme - 4
Music - 5 (love Overklock 
)
Visual Elements - 3.75 (points taken off for too much Trollface Chanel and so little Kasia)
Effectiveness - 3
Likability - 4
Round #47 Score: Victoria's Secret Holiday 2010
80.29
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ROUND 48
Very Sexy Push-Up (2006)
Mood/Theme (The feeling, tone and message the commercial is conveying---How good of a job did the commercial achieve this?)
Music (How appropriate & fitting was the music? How much did you like the music?)
Visual Elements (Camera angles & shots, scenes, editing, transitions, effects, filters, etc.---How much did you like the visual elements?)
Effectiveness (How well did the commercial promote the featured product(s)? Did the commercial persuade you to want to purchase the product(s)? Did the voice-over or lack of it help?)
Likability (Overall how much did you like the commercial?)
Copy & Paste the following onto a new post to rate:
Mood/Theme
Music
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability
Mood/Theme 3.5
Music 3.5
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 3
Likability 4
Mood/Theme 2
Music 2
Visual Elements 2,5 (Sorry but this is more like a night/strip club commercial..) 
Effectiveness 3
Likability 1
Mood/Theme 4.5
Music 3
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 4
Likability 4
Mood/Theme 4
Music 3.7
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 4
Likability 4
Mood/Theme
Music
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability
3.5 for all 
Oooh I was waiting for this one.
Mood/Theme: 5
Music: Can I give it a 100? 
The great Jimi Hendrix can't have less than that
Visual Elements: 5
Effectiveness: 5
Likability: 5!
Can't get any better than Ale, Gisele and JIMI HENDRIX!!!!