Fragrance vs. Cosmetics Commercial Ultimate Battle...to the Death! ^_^

Debon- how cheesy,boring, and not exicuted well, Alyssa did look gorgeous at the end though- 1

VS- I liked the idea but it just wasn't shot very well, i likey the horsey though <3 2

Maybelline- hmmm, funny how they all have the same singing voice,i didn't like the closeup of the lashes either as it shows they are false, i like the red and the girls did look gorgeous- 1.5

Valentino V- awh that was cute, i don't like the model though- 4

But i'm not judging you. I know I've done worse you do not need to remember.

But you are still one of the best ever and are running two of the best comps at the same time.

Oh you're a love but I'm really bad at times lool

Debon: 2 but she really looked great in the end

VS: 3 At first I thought of giving five... then four... but don is right, I was surprised too how amateur it does look. Although wonderful idea.

Maybelline: 5

Valentino: 3

I guess just a couple more will do .

bump

Debon: 3 - Well, it's not that bad...Like that lipstick colour on her.

VS: 5 - White horse + Gisele + trees! WIN!

Maybelline: 5 - OMG. A well executed Maybelline commercial. I can't complain about anything? One of my favourites of this comp so far.

Valentino: 1 - Doesn't speak to me at all.

Debon 3

Victoria's Secret 4

Maybelline 4.5

Valentino 1.5

Debon 3.5

VS 3

Maybelline 4

Valentino 2

Debon: 1

VS: 1

Maybelline: 5

Valentino: 3

bump

Debon: 2.5

VS: 1.5

Maybelline: 5

Valentino: 2

RESULTS

Debon = 2.59375

VS Dream = 2.84

Maybelline Lash Stiletto = 4.25

Valentino V = 2.4

Revlon - 2

Christian Lacroix - 3 extra 2 points because of the contrast between the dress and the woods, though a wolf or something would have helped the cause .

YSL - 2.5 sure is gussied up just to stand around in the living room. There's a big world out there waiting for her, but sometimes you have to do it just for you I guess .

Dior - 1.5

Revlon 5

Christian Lacroix 4

YSL 4

Dior 2

Revlon 2

Lacroix 1

YSL 3

Dior 1

Revlon - Jessica is really selling it in this commercial. I would have prefered another music though, and the guy is useless 3

Lacroix - 4

YSL - For what's happening in this commercial, even 30 seconds is too long 1

Dior - Love Carmen but I'm not a big fan of this 2

Revlon 1.5

Lacroix 3.8

YSL 1

Dior 1

Revlon - Pharrell? really? how random- Jessica looked pretty but it was boring - B&W is beautiful but the content has to be great otheriwse it bores me. - 1.5

Christian Lacroix- lovely (; reminded me of a fairytale- annoying voiceover though- 4

YSL- would have been great if it was half the length- way too long and nothing exciting happened- beautiful model though- 2.8

J'adore Dior- unique and clever idea but wasn't executed well- i dislike Carmen too- 2

Revlon: 3 - Why on earth is Pharrell in this? They should have concentrated on the product and Jessica not so much on him.

Christian Lacroix: 3 - Pretty. And there is a great chemistry between these two.

YSL: 5 - Actually, I love it. Yes it's too long but you immediately know what they want to sell and she's looking amazing.

Dior: 2 - This is kinda stiff and silly. Something about it disturbs me.

Revlon;; 3.5

I love Jessica Biel, but the video is a little long for me S:

Lacroix;; 3

YSL;; 1.5

Just because the song is spanish (:

Dior;; 1.5