Fragrance vs. Cosmetics Commercial Ultimate Battle...to the Death! ^_^

Covergirl, love the look 3.5

Brit, blahhhhhhh 2.5

Estee L so so, kinda bland 1.5

Very V hate to say i like this one, love the instense look of the model, but its not telling me BUY this perfume so 4

Covergir- Never found Drew attractive at all but i adore her voice,it's sexy and strong- loved the lighting,visuals and goofyness- 4.

Britney - I don't get it little point for the hot dude though- 0.5

Estee Lauder- hahahaha this commercial looks so old,like dinosaur roaming the earth old Paulina looked gorgeous but i dislike the music and stupid guys voice-over, nice lighting though. - 1

Valentino- had no purpose,stupid heavy breathing- nice dress and model though- 1.5

CoverGirl 3

Curious 4

Estee Lauder 2

Very Valentino 2.3

Drew Barrymore Covergirl 2010 Makeup Collection Ad - 1

Britney Spears Curious Perfume Commercial - 4.5

Estee Lauder More Than Mascara - 3

Valentino "Very Valentino" Perfume Commercial - 4.5

Covergirl: 5

I can't truthfully say I'm a Drew fan but in terms of visuals, lighting and vibrant colours, this ad is as good as it gets.

Britney: 1.5

Didn't appear to be selling anything but Britney, and I'm afraid I'm not buying.

Estee Lauder: 1.5

Not completely without merit but overall, tremendously dated in virtually every department.

Valentino: 3

Perhaps lacking in substance but I liked the colours a lot and the model looks great.

CoverGirl 1

Curious 0

Estee Lauder 3

Very Valentino 2

Estee Lauder- hahahaha this commercial looks so old,like dinosaur roaming the earth old

Revlon - 2.5 - not a fan of hers, but cute anyway.

Emily - 3 I know you're thinking she hasn't learned to model yet and that may be true, but she sure is pretty and has kindof a pleasant way about her. She's like your partner in lab who takes off the glasses and everyone else notices her magically, but you knew all along . Though it seems more could have been done with it as well and her lack of genuine sensuality (which is made up for by girl next door sweetness in Maybelline ads) makes it look more like a runaway girl than a wilderness woman, but well shot.

Garnier - 2.5

Prada - 1 - hated it, but nice try.

Revlon 3

Emily 3.5

Garnier 1

Prada 3

Revlon Sugar Bianca Balti-I just dont like her face, to manish for me 1 point

Acqua di Gioia - Giorgio Armani with Emily Didonato-LOVE her in this one, super sexy, BUT i wouldnt know it was a perfume commercial from just watching, soooo 4 points

Cynthia Kirchner Garnier Fructis-only nice part of this commerical is her HAIR, its BEAUTIFUL 1 point

Prada Fragrance-I know its just me, but the hair makes me think of the Cone heads blahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh .5 points

Revlon - 4- short & sweet, would not buy this weird product but Bianca looked gorgeous and the sparkles were nice.

Giorgio Armarni- 4.5- gorgeous lighting,gorgeous model,gorgeous scenary= gorgeous commercial.

Garnier Fructic- 2.5- she does have beautiful hair but it was a boring commercial and too long.

Prada- 1 i hate this commercial,i rmber everytime it came on tv i'd go out of the room- it freaks me out.

Revlon 2

Giorgio Armani 3

Garnier 2.5

Prada 0.5

Revlon 2

Giorgio Armani 5

Garnier 2.5

Prada 0.5

Revlon - 2.5

Armani - 3.5

Garnier - 3

Prada - 1

Revlon 3

Emily 1

Garnier 1

Prada 1

Emily 5

Revlon 2

Emily 4

Garnier 2.5

Prada 3

Don there's a huge difference between a commercial that's crappy (ie. bad green screen, a theme that doesn't match the product, takes to long to get to what it's selling, horrible lighting, cheesy selling points, bad acting... which btw most of the stuff we've been voting for falls under in some form for me ), and one that is visually stunning on such a level that it's able to step away from the product it's trying to sell, still holds its own and keep your attention. Either perfume, or a tropical vacation... both are being sold to me.

Is it the best commercial ever for me: No but based on the commercials we've already voted on, it's aesthetically the most pleasing for me. Nature vs Green Screen

Does the commercial make me want to go to Hawaii: Yes

Does the commercial make me want to run around naked in the rain: Yes lol

Does the commercial inspire me artistically: Yes

Is the commercial well done: Yes

Does the commercial make me curious to see if the product lives up the the gorgeousness of the commercial: Yes

Do I like the model in the commercial: Yesish Depends on the day.

Does the commercial legitimately inspire me to not only say I want to go to Hawaii, but actually do so: Yes. It got my hubby and I talking about a possible vacation in the near future before he begins his new job. Both of us really liked the black sandy beaches. /nods

So yes Don... High Five for logic. (Y)

But here's what I'm going to do just for you since it seems to be an issue. I'm going to ignore all it's strong selling points and strictly vote for it based on it being too long for ya. (psst the airing commercial is only 15 secs which I've seen it dozens of time, and when the perfume came out I was inspired to buy the product which is sitting in my bathroom right now and I wear it all the time ... but that never could of swayed the reason for a score of 5 in addition to all it's other selling points... never) Score has been changed accordingly. Thanks for the reminder of my /fail logic

Onto something more awesometastic. I thought of you Joesph when I saw this

Revlon 4

Emily 5

Garnier 1

Prada 4

Revlon - 2,5

Emily - 5

Garnier - 3 her hair is great.

Prada - 0