Best VS Commercial of 2014 Competition - RESULTS
529 replies · 63444 views
Mood/Theme 4.5
Music 4.5
Visual Elements 4.5
Effectiveness 4.5
Likability 4.5
Mood/Theme 4
Music 4.5
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 4
Likability 4.5
Mood/Theme 5
Music 3
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 4
Likability 5
Victoria’s Secret Holiday 2014: What Angels Want (Director’s Cut)
Mood/Theme - 4
Music - 5
Visual Elements - 4.5
Effectiveness - 3
Likability - 4.5
Mood/Theme: 3,8
Music: 4
Visual Elements: 3,8
Effectiveness: 3,7
Likability: 3,8
Round #36 Score: Victoria’s Secret Holiday 2014: What Angels Want (Director’s Cut)
64.66
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Complete Results Available Soon...
Best VS Commercial of 2014 - Results
THE BEST: Holiday 2014: What Angels Want (Extended Cut)
Points: 84.75
2. Holiday 2014: What Angels Want (Director’s Cut)
Points: 78.98
(Refer to #1 video)
3. Fearless TV Commercial
Points: 74.66
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SACOatsrsok
4. Dream Angels Online Commercial (Holiday 2014)
Points: 70.17
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OpPhKkVrJaU
5. Very Sexy Scandalous Online Commercial (Extended Cut)
Points: 69.71
6. "$20 Reward Card with Any $75 Purchase" TV Commercial (December 2014)
Points: 67.84
Here are the rest of the rankings and scores. The number in brackets refers to the round the commercial was featured in.
7. VS "Beach Towel" Offer TV Commercial (Spring/Summer 2014) = 66.25 [29]
8. Incredible by Victoria's Secret Online Commercial (May 2014) = 66.18 [20]
9. Body by Victoria TV Commercial (September 2014) = 65.72 [33]
10. Victoria’s Secret Heavenly Luxe TV Commercial (Holiday 2014) = 65.48 [13]
11. Victoria’s Secret Fearless Online Commercial = 65.28 [28]
12. Body by Victoria Online Commercial (March 2014) = 64.66 [35]
13. Victoria’s Secret Dream Angels TV Commercial (Holiday 2014) = 62.90 [25]
14. VS "Gifts For $30 Or Less" TV Commercial (December 2014) = 62.45 [3]
15. VS "50% Off Panties" TV Commercial (December 2014) = 61.2 [14]
16. Heavenly Luxe Online Commercial (Holiday 2014) = 60.8 [1]
17. Pink Loves "Black and White" (Fall 2014) = 56.66 [11]
18. VS PINK: Rose Lace Collection (Spring 2014) = 55.5 [30]
19. Victoria's Secret Very Sexy Online Commercial (Extended Cut) (Spring 2014) = 54.75 [21]
20. Victoria's Secret Very Sexy TV Commercial (Spring 2014) = 54.5 [17]
21. Victoria’s Secret Very Sexy Scandalous TV Commercial = 54.37 [9]
22. Victoria’s Secret Scandalous Fragrance Video (October 2014) = 54.22 [5]
23. Body by Victoria TV Commercial (March 2014) = 54.15 [12]
24. 2014 PINK Campus Essentials = 53.30 [4]
25. VS "Buy One Bra Get One 50% Off" TV Commercial (November/December 2014) = 53.15 [6]
26. VS "Free Slippers" TV Commercial (Holiday 2014) = 51.12 [26]
27. VS "Scandalously Sexy Bracelet" TV Commercial (Mid-Fall 2014) = 50.6 [22]
28. Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show 2014 TV Promo = 50.1 [25]
29. VS "Beauty Gifts For $30 Or Less" TV Commercial (December 2014) = 49.09 [32]
30. Victoria's Secret Introduces Eau So Sexy Places to Wear Fragrance = 48.3 [18]
31. Victoria's Secret T-Shirt Bra TV Commercial = 47.09 [7]
32. Incredible by Victoria's Secret TV Commercial (May 2014) = 43.87 [8]
33. Online Exclusive: Victoria's Secret Heavenly = 42.91 [24]
34. VS Black Friday Tote TV Commercial (2014) = 40.92 [19]
35. Victoria's Secret "Simple Sexy" TV Commercial = 38.73 [2]
36. VSFS 2014 Official Promos = 30.01 [34]
Looks like VS needs to shoot abroad more often from the looks of the results 
Thank you Pinky for all your efforts and work 
Thank you all for your participation and taking time to vote!!! 
Another Potential Competition...
I am considering starting another similar competition in the Spring involving the best overall VS commercial (thank you Prettyphile for the suggestion 
) It could be any TV or online commercial, including extended and director's cut, from any year as long as it is on either YouTube or Vimeo. Those are the only 2 sites I know of we could embed videos from. If anyone is interested please send me a PM with the link(s) to the commercial(s). Any comments/questions are welcome 
Again, thanks for all your support of this competition!!! 
Love the Top 3 commercials. These are my favorite, too 
Thx for your effort, PC!
Love the #1! Though I wish Elsa's commercial would have been higher 
Amazing job with the competition, PC Can't wait for the next one 
Awesome comp PC! Great work! And love the idea for the other comp
Great comp Pink! Thanks for all the efforts.
The overall VS commercial idea sounds good too.
I love the idea of best overall commercial because there are some amazing VS commercials that will get big votes. Like the 2008 holiday commercial which was one of their best ever. Loved this comp too. Thanks PC for running it. I'll send you a PM when I get a chance with some commercial choices.