Best VS Commercial of 2014 Competition - RESULTS

Mood/Theme 3

Music 2

Visual Elements 3

Effectiveness 2

Likability 2

Mood/Theme - 3.5

Music - 4.5

Visual Elements - 3

Effectiveness - 2

Likability - 2

Mood/Theme: 3.5

Music: 2.5

Visual Elements: 4

Effectiveness: 3

Likability: 3.5

Mood/Theme: 2.5

Music: 2

Visual Elements: 3

Effectiveness: 2

Likability: 2.5

Mood/Theme: 1.85 - see music

Music: 1.5 - I actually felt uncomfortable by the music???? Idk why but this commercial was just a big turn off for me

Visual Elements: 3.7 - LOVE light v. dark contrast in cinematography so gotta give props here

Effectiveness: 1.9

Likeability: 2 - felt like some more sultry music really would've fit a lot better, the light jazzy-pop wasn't doing it for me

Mood/Theme - 4

Music - 3

Visual Elements - 4.5

Effectiveness - 3

Likability - 4

This round of voting is over. Next round will be up soon.

Round # 1 Score: Victoria’s Secret Heavenly Luxe Online Commercial (Holiday 2014)
60.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ROUND 2
Victoria's Secret "Simple Sexy" TV Commercial

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjEZ8-Z3nQA

Please rated the commercial on a scale of 1-5 (5 being the "best" score) on each of the following 5 criteria:
Mood/Theme (The feeling, tone and message the commercial is conveying---How good of a job did the commercial achieve this?)
Music (How appropriate and fitting was the music? How much did you like the music?)
Visual Elements (Camera angles & shots, scenes, editing, transitions, effects, filters, etc.---How much did you like the visual elements?)
Effectiveness (How well did the commercial promote the product it was trying to sell? Did the voiceover or lack of it helped?)
Likability (Overall how much did you like the commercial?)

Copy & Paste the following onto a new post to rate:
Mood/Theme
Music
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability

Mood/Theme - 4.75
Music - 4.5
Visual Elements - 2
Effectiveness - 2
Likability - 1.75

Mood/Theme 4
Music 1
Visual Elements 1.5
Effectiveness i'm not a girl lol so ... 1
Likability 1

Very bad one imo

Mood/Theme - 3

Music - 1

Visual Elements - 2.5

Effectiveness - 3

Likability - 2

Mood/Theme 3 (well... it's simple, as the name of the commercial)
Music 1.5 (love the song, just don't like it in the commercial)
Visual Elements 2 (booooring, give me an editing software and I'll do something better, for sure)
Effectiveness 2.5 (meeeh, normal)
Likability 2 (just... TOO simple)

Mood/Theme :thumbsdown: 1.5
Music 1 (like tiika above, I actually like the song, just not here)
Visual Elements 1
Effectiveness 2
Likability 2 

Mood/Theme: 2
Music: 1
Visual Elements: 2.5
Effectiveness: 2
Likability: 1

Mood/Theme 2

Music 3

Visual Elements 2

Effectiveness 1

Likability 2

Mood: 1 - bored to hell and the commercial is only 15 seconds long

Music: 1

Visual Elements: 0 - I could put this together in photoshop

Effectiveness: 1

Likeability: 0.5 - I feel like I'm being very generous here

Mood/Theme - 2.5
Music - 4
Visual Elements - 3
Effectiveness - 3
Likability - 1.5

Mood/Theme - 4
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 3
Effectiveness - 2.5
Likability - 3

Mood/Theme 1.5
Music 1
Visual Elements 1
Effectiveness 1
Likability 1

Mood/Theme 1
Music 1
Visual Elements 1.5
Effectiveness 3
Likability 1