Fragrance vs. Cosmetics Commercial Ultimate Battle...to the Death! ^_^

At least a couple more would be good . As a side note though, one interresting irony of the polls is that the commercials with male models have the most 5s whereas if I were to do a male commercial comp probably half the people would vote . Or at least the average male model would probably get higher scores whereas the females are still more popular.

I´ve never been much interested in male models but good commercial is a good commercial, no matter who is there

Marloes could have been writhing around with The Elephant Man, and I'd still give it 5

Maybelline: 2

Fuel for Life: 5 - Lol at choosing such a cheesy Disco track.

Chanel: 5 - Simple and glamouros.

Valentino: 5 - Mona!

Mary Kay: 1.5 - No, no, no- I really hate the song. Everything is a little bit too happy for me here.

Estee Lauder: 3.5 - Pretty.

Maybelline - Typical Maybelline but it still works 3.5

Diesel - Sexy but not too tacky, fun, with a lot of energy. Love it 5

Chanel - I love the luxury feel of this commercial 4.5

Valentino - Good but not great 3.5

Mary Kay - Cheezy 1.5

Estee Lauder - Cute 3.5

I'll work on making this a little easier on the eyes ...

ROUND 1

Pair 1

Cheryl Cole Loreal - 1.91875

Raquel & Natasha Gucci Perfume Commercial - 1.6

Winner: Cosmetics

ROUND 2

Pair 2

Gisele - 3.5

Maybelline - 2.272

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 3

Chanel - 3.972

Lux - 1.88

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 3

Pair 4

Scarlett Johansson D&G The One - 2.5

Josie Maran Volum Express Maybelline New York - 2.6294

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 5

Angie Everhart Finesse Commercial - 1.08823

Gwen Stefani's Harajuku Lovers Fragrance - 1.4294

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 4

Pair 6

Veronica Varekova Nivea Mascara - 2

"Ricci Ricci" Perfume Commercial with Jessica Stam - 3.55

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 7

Taylor Swift CoverGirl NatureLuxe - 2.565

Kenzo Flower Fragrance - 2.825

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 5

Pair 8

Revlon Colorstay Lipstick - 3.1333

Victoria's Secret Fragrance - 3.22857 (to be altered as one voted before commercial was changed)

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 9

Fit Me Foundation Maybelline New York - 3.453

-Midnight Poison by C Dior - 3.64

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 6

Pair 10

Drew Barrymore Covergirl Makeup Collection - 2.44375

Britney Spears Curious Perfume - 1.83125

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 11

Estee Lauder More than Mascara - 2

Valentino "Very Valentino" -2.525

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 7

Pair 12

Bianca - 2.6875

Emily - 4.09375

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 13

-Garnier - 1.9375

Prada - 1.53125

Winner: Cosmetics

ROUND 13

Pair 14

Garnier - 1.66428

Kate - 3.19999

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 15

Revlon - 2.307

Cacharel - 2.8718

Winner: Cosmetics

ROUND 14

Pair 16

Shania Twain Revlon Colorstay Makeup - 2.142857

Britney Spears Fantasy Fragrance - 1.55

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 17

Aishwarya Rai Loreal - 2.0769

Juicy Couture Fragrance - 3.53571

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 15

Pair 18

Maybelline - 2.916

Miss Dior - 3.75

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 19

Julie Ordon Chanel - 3.0416

Evanteline Lily Cool Water Woman - 2.7083

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 16

Pair 20

Milla Jovovich L'Oreal Rouge Pulp - 2.708

Yves Saint Laurent YSL Paris Perfume - 1.508

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 21

Scarlett Johansson L'Oreal HIP - 1.683

Daria Werbowy Lancome Hypnose Senses - 3.425

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 17

Pair 22

Lancome Lipstick - 2.1125

Theorema Fendi - 2.46875

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 23

Color Rich L'Oreal - 2.6875

Stella McCartney - 2.9625

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 18

Pair 24

Anna Sui - 1.87

Forbidden Rose - 2.266

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 25

Dior Addict - 2.583

Chanel Number 5 - 3.875

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 19

Pair 26

Maybelline New York Fit Me Foundation - 3.0066

Inspire Perfume - 1.1066

Pair 27

L'Oreal Perfect Slim - 1.94

With Love Perfume - 1.613

ROUND 20

Pair 28

Maybelline New York Fit Me Foundation - 3.0066

Inspire Perfume - 1.1066

Pair 29

L'Oreal Perfect Slim - 1.94

With Love Perfume - 1.613

ROUND 21

Pair 30

Maybelline - 3.43

Givenchy - 2.66

Pair 31

Max Factor - 1.9

Versace - 2.125

ROUND 22

Pair 32

Lux - 34.9

Estee Lauder Pomegrante Power - 29.7

Pair 33

Cover Perfume - 35

Dior Pure Poison - 33.1

ROUND 23

Pair 34

Maybelline - 3.225

Guerlain - 3.34375

Pair 35

Maybelline - 2.59375

Dolce - 3.4375

RESULTS

Loreal = 1.86

Guerlain Mahora = 3.26

Maybelline Cat Eye Mascara = 2.43

Guilty Gucci = 3.86

RESULTS

Debon = 2.59375

VS Dream = 2.84

Maybelline Lash Stiletto = 4.25

Valentino V = 2.4

RESULTS

Revlon - 32.2/2.4769

Christian Lacroix - 38.3/2.946

YSL - 34.3/2.858

Dior - 21.5/1.6538

RESULTS

Loreal - 3.6

Thermasilk - 3.75

Nina Ricchi - 3.37857

Robert Cavali - 3.25

RESULTS

Versache Pur Femme - 2.115

Cover Girl Silk Foundation - 2.4615

Olay Body Wash - 2.964

Angel Thierry Mugler - 2.721

RESULTS

Mary Kay Color - 37/15=2.466

Miss Dior Cherie - 44.5/15=2.966

Dior Addict Makeup - 2.066

Bruno Avelain Lanvin Oxygene - 52.7/3.513

RESULTS

Mary Kay Commercial - 3.375

Guerlain Inastand Magic - 2.625

Maybelline New York Watershine Elixer - 1.958

Gaultier Madame Perfume - 2.875

Avon - 2 Kindof liked the hand motion .

Scarlett - 1.5

Revlon - 1.5

Boss - 1

Avon - 2.5 Nice try .

Cacharel - 1 I need either my involvement or an extremely moving story (that includes an epic adventure) to make guy on girl kissing relevant for me, but nice try .

Avon 2

Cacharel 2

Revlon 3

Hugo Boss 3

Avon 2

Cacharel - Awwwwww this send me back in past 5

Avon Clear Skin;; 2

Scarlett;; 4.5

Revlon;; 1

Boss;; 2.5

Avon Aney;; 1.5

Cacharel;; 4

Avon 3

Cacharell 4

Revlon 1

Boss 3

Avon Emulsions 1.5

Amor Amor 2.5

For COP11

Avon 1

Cacharell 1

Revlon 5

Boss 1

Avon Emulsions 5-for having pretty woman according to her

Amor AMor 1

Avon 2.5

Cacharel 2

Revlon 1

Hugo Boss 5

Avon 4.5 (only Nicole's Trunfio part)

Cacharel 2

Avon Clearskin - 3 Decent, gets the point across.

Scarlett - 2 was cute and catchy, but I don't remember it after it played.

Revlon - 4 it was old school, when it was new school.

Boss - 2 I'm sure I'd like the fragrance, but I could only think of how the director was telling her how to emote for the camera.

Avon Anew - 3 UK gets the better Anew ads than we do in the states.

(I hope I did it right, first time doing this)

Cacharel - 1

Avon- She won miss Universe?! Annoying voices, but i liked the colours,lol - 2

Scarlett Cacharell- That was cute && i love Skye- 4.5

Revlon- I liked it but why was Claudia trying to be all sexy wearing those dresses and shaking around....i thought this was a lipstick ad? - 4

Boss- Loving the music- and Sienna looked quite adorable but it was kinda pointless .... - 2.5

Avon Anew- Once again,simple & got to the point- beautiful models too- 4.3

Cacharell- DAYUM, they were really going at it weren't they? that dude was trying to eat her face off..... i don't get this one.... 1

Avon: 2.5 - Simple, effective, but fairly unremarkable.

Scarlett Cacharel: 4 - Very very (very) cute.

Revlon: 3 - Very much of its time, but it gets to the point quickly and holds your attention.

Boss: 5 - Though I'm not generally that fussed about Sienna, I've always found this ad rather magnificent.

Avon Anew: 3.5 - Pretty standard stuff but the nice use of primary colours makes it more memorable than most.

Cacharel: 2 - Get a room guys. Oh, you already did.

Avon: 3

Scarlett Cacharell: 3.8

Revlon: 4.5

Boss: 2

Avon Anew: 2

Cacharell: 1

Avon Clear Skin - The commercial is ok, but I don't like when they try to get some "scientist" to approve of the product 2

Scarlett - I just like Skye 3

Revlon - Claudia looks good I guess 3

Hugo Boss - For what's happening in the commercial, it's a little too long 2

Avon Anew - I don't like the use of young women in wrinkle reducing products, other than that, it's alright 2.5

Cacharel - Very cute 3.5

Avon: 3. Not bad, and not annoying.

Scarlett: 4. Pretty cute. The music fits well, although it's a bad rendition

Revlon: 1.5. Annoying :| +0.5 for the colour idea.

Boss: 3.5. Speaking of bad covers.. <_< A bit long, but charming if a little pointless

Avon: 2.5. Dull and without much polish, but Nicole FTW :brows:

Cacharel: 5. Love it

Avon Clear Skin: 1 - Uhm "embarassing Acne"? Kinda stupid. The commercial is ok but I really dislike this woman. Miss Universe can not convince me to buy anything, sorry.

Scarlett Cacharel: 5 - Yes, I do agree with Pretty but I still think this is very cute and well made.

Revlon: 3.5 - This is kinda...good.

Boss Orange: 4.5 - I like that it is fresh and careless but it's still a little bit staged. Just a bit. Sienna is adorable, though.

Avon Aney Emulsions: 1.5 - Those faces are a little bit too plain for my taste. Too much high-tech in this one!

Cacharel Amor Amor: 1 - Does not touch me. At all.