244 replies · 56758 views














#1 Kathy Ireland#2 Cheryl Tiegs --> Genevieve Morton#3 Elle Macpherson#4 Christie Brinkley --> Josie Maran#5 Daniela Pestova --> Nina Agdal#6 Yamila Diaz-Rahi#7 Paulina Porizkova#8 Veronica Varekova#9 Irina Shayk#10 Heidi Klum#11 Carol Alt --> Lucia Dvorska#12 Rebecca Romijn#13 Ashley Richardson#14 Anne Vyalitsyna#15 Rachel Hunter
i think it's interesting how, when SI put out their rankings, people here complained that they seemed skewed towards more recent models. and yet when you give them the opportunity to rank, they skew even further towards...more recent models! i mean, i like genevieve, josie, and nina, but their contributions to SI really pale in comparison to any one of the three girls they defeated (cheryl, christie, or daniela).
i'll go ahead and bet now that even #1 seed kathy ireland will be beat by either marisa miller or petra nemcova. elle will be the only high-seeded girl to make it to the final four.
i think it's interesting how, when SI put out their rankings, people here complained that they seemed skewed towards more recent models. and yet when you give them the opportunity to rank, they skew even further towards...more recent models! i mean, i like genevieve, josie, and nina, but their contributions to SI really pale in comparison to any one of the three girls they defeated (cheryl, christie, or daniela).
i'll go ahead and bet now that even #1 seed kathy ireland will be beat by either marisa miller or petra nemcova. elle will be the only high-seeded girl to make it to the final four.
I think it's because there's a lot more models in the recent SI years than in the past SI years, so statistically more recent models are more likely to get selected. Also a lot will depend on the selected picture and how they look in it compared to the picture of the other model. But the current "top 15" looks statistically more representative of all the SI models than the previous one.

i think it's interesting how, when SI put out their rankings, people here complained that they seemed skewed towards more recent models. and yet when you give them the opportunity to rank, they skew even further towards...more recent models! i mean, i like genevieve, josie, and nina, but their contributions to SI really pale in comparison to any one of the three girls they defeated (cheryl, christie, or daniela).
i'll go ahead and bet now that even #1 seed kathy ireland will be beat by either marisa miller or petra nemcova. elle will be the only high-seeded girl to make it to the final four.
I think it's because there's a lot more models in the recent SI years than in the past SI years, so statistically more recent models are more likely to get selected. Also a lot will depend on the selected picture and how they look in it compared to the picture of the other model. But the current "top 15" looks statistically more representative of all the SI models than the previous one.
I think you both make great points. The interesting thing about the tournament is that it's a tournament format, not just a straight rank of models. So, it has led to some interesting results. For example, Daniela Pestova got knocked out by Nina Agdal in the second round, but I think (personal opinion) that both would make the top 15-20 models list. Nina needs more years and a cover, but has the look. But, Daniela got bounced from the tourney and would not be in the "top 32" if you chose to look at it that way. But, she clearly is. Similarly, some have had an easier draw and have ended up in the final 32 when I would not have expected them to. (Think Shannan Click, Kristy Hinze, or Hannah Davis.)
UK is correct about the photo being judged relative to the other model's photo. More, though, it's each model being judged on the other model. That is what it is, really... a bunch of head-to-head matchups. When selecting a photo, I've been basically using the model's last remaining best (my opinion) unused photo. I've also tended to use similar poses for each model, when available, as to not have the photo itself be too much of an influence.
I'm glad it's generating some debate. It's been an interesting competition so far!


I totally knew Marisa would slay Petra, it's such a shame she went MIA from the modeling world

(I need to ask, what does "MIA" stands for?
)