Best VS Commercial of 2014 Competition - RESULTS

Round #13 Score: Victoria’s Secret Heavenly Luxe TV Commercial (Holiday 2014)

65.48
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ROUND 14
VS "50% Off Panties" TV Commercial (December 2014)
Note: Commercial scenes different from previously posted

Please rated the commercial on a scale of 1-5 (5 being the "best" score) on each of the following 5 criteria:
Mood/Theme (The feeling, tone and message the commercial is conveying---How good of a job did the commercial achieve this?)
Music (How appropriate and fitting was the music? How much did you like the music?)
Visual Elements (Camera angles & shots, scenes, editing, transitions, effects, filters, etc.---How much did you like the visual elements?)
Effectiveness (How well did the commercial promote the product it was trying to sell? Did the voice over or lack of it helped?)
Likability (Overall how much did you like the commercial?)
 
Copy & Paste the following onto a new post to rate:
Mood/Theme
Music
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability

Mood/Theme 4
Music 4
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 3
Likability 4

Mood/Theme: 3
Music: 2
Visual Elements: 3.5
Effectiveness: 3.5
Likability: 4

Mood/Theme 4
Music 3,5
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 3,5
Likability 4,5

Mood/Theme 2
Music 1
Visual Elements 3
Effectiveness 3
Likability 1

Mood/Theme 2
Music 1
Visual Elements 3
Effectiveness 2
Likability 2

Mood/Theme 3
Music 2.5
Visual Elements 3
Effectiveness 3
Likability 3

Mood/Theme - 2
Music -1 
Visual Elements - 2 (I would have preferred the same type of commercial, I really hate mismatching shots) 
Effectiveness - 4
Likability - 1.5

VS "50% Off Panties" TV Commercial (December 2014)

Mood/Theme - 3.75
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 4 (wish we saw more of Candice's first and last scene. Karlie's scene didn't flow with the other)
Effectiveness - 2.75 (showed more bras than panties)
Likability - 4

Mood/Theme 3.5

Music 2
Visual Elements 4.5 (the girls all look really good)
Effectiveness 2.5
Likability 3

Round #14 Score: VS "50% Off Panties" TV Commercial (December 2014)

61.2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ROUND 15
Victoria’s Secret Fearless TV Commercial
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SACOatsrsok

Please rated the commercial on a scale of 1-5 (5 being the "best" score) on each of the following 5 criteria:
Mood/Theme (The feeling, tone and message the commercial is conveying---How good of a job did the commercial achieve this?)
Music (How appropriate and fitting was the music? How much did you like the music?)
Visual Elements (Camera angles & shots, scenes, editing, transitions, effects, filters, etc.---How much did you like the visual elements?)
Effectiveness (How well did the commercial promote the product it was trying to sell? Did the voice over or lack of it helped?)
Likability (Overall how much did you like the commercial?)
 
Copy & Paste the following onto a new post to rate:
Mood/Theme
Music
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability

Mood/Theme 2.5
Music 1.5
Visual Elements 2.5
Effectiveness 2
Likability 1.5

Mood/Theme 5
Music 3
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 5
Likability 4.6

Mood/Theme 3.5
Music 4
Visual Elements 2.5
Effectiveness 3
Likability 3

Mood/Theme: 4
Music: 1.5
Visual Elements: 3.5
Effectiveness: 3
Likability: 4

Mood/Theme 4
Music 3.5
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 4
Likability 4

Mood/Theme 4

Music 3

Visual Elements 4

Effectiveness 4

Likability 4

Victoria’s Secret Fearless TV Commercial
Mood/Theme - 4.5
Music - 3
Visual Elements - 4 (scenes flowed pretty well and length was decent)
Effectiveness - 3.75
Likability - 3.5

Mood/Theme 4
Music 3.5
Visual Elements 4
Effectiveness 4
Likability 4