Best VS Commercial of 2014 Competition - RESULTS

Mood/Theme: 3
Music: 2.5
Visual Elements: 3.5
Effectiveness: 3.5
Likability: 3

VS "Gifts For $30 Or Less" TV Commercial (December 2014)

 

Mood/Theme - 3.75

Music - 3

Visual Elements - 3

Effectiveness - 4

Likability - 3.5

+1

This round of voting is over. Next round will be up soon.

Round # 3 Score: VS "Gifts For $30 Or Less" TV Commercial (December 2014)

62.45

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ROUND 4
2014 PINK Campus Essentials

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7DkvMBH3Sc

Please rated the commercial on a scale of 1-5 (5 being the "best" score) on each of the following 5 criteria:
Mood/Theme (The feeling, tone and message the commercial is conveying---How good of a job did the commercial achieve this?)
Music (How appropriate and fitting was the music? How much did you like the music?)
Visual Elements (Camera angles & shots, scenes, editing, transitions, effects, filters, etc.---How much did you like the visual elements?)
Effectiveness (How well did the commercial promote the product it was trying to sell? Did the voiceover or lack of it helped?)
Likability (Overall how much did you like the commercial?)

Copy & Paste the following onto a new post to rate:
Mood/Theme
Music
Visual Elements
Effectiveness
Likability

2014 PINK Campus Essentials

Mood/Theme - 1.5
Music - 1
Visual Elements - 1.15
Effectiveness - 2.5
Likability - 1.75

2014 PINK Campus Essentials

Mood/Theme - 3.5
Music - 1.5
Visual Elements - 3
Effectiveness - 2.5
Likability - 4

Mood/Theme 4

Music 4.5

Visual Elements 2

Effectiveness 2

Likability 3

I must also add that I hate when she does that peace sign dance :| . 

Mood/Theme 4
Music 4.5
Visual Elements 2
Effectiveness 2
Likability 3

Mood/theme: 2 - i like the idea but between the music and editing i'm getting too much of a boogie nights vibe from this commercial and i feel like that should be the last thing i associate with collegiate attire...

Music: 1 - see above

Visual elements: 2.75 - i enjoy the retro concepts but once again see above

Effectiveness: 1.5 - da f*ck are they selling? what?

Likability: 2.5

Mood/Theme: 3
Music: 1.5       Not really THAT bad... it seemed to fit (?). I was thinking about 3. But it's THE SAME DAMN PATTERN over and over again for a whole minute so...
Visual Elements: 4
Effectiveness: 2
Likability: 3

Mood/Theme: 2.5

Music: 1.5

Visual Elements: 2.5

Effectiveness: 2

Likability: 2.5

Mood/Theme 3 - well is not THAT bad, Jac and Elsa make it funny.
Music 2.5 - like it, but too repetitive.
Visual Elements 3 - I love all the concept, it's like old or something like that (?) IDK
Effectiveness 1 - I just see 86's and stuff.... what are they selling?
Likability 4 - the models give a +2.5

Mood/Theme 3
Music 4
Visual Elements 2.5
Effectiveness 1.5
Likability 4

Mood/Theme - 2.5

Music - 3
Visual Elements - 1

Effectiveness - 3

Likability - 2

Effectiveness: 1.5 - da f*ck are they selling? what?

 

Effectiveness 1 - I just see 86's and stuff.... what are they selling?

Supposedly campus wear and "essentials"

The football field can be interpreted many ways, but they were briefly shown coming down the school stairs at least . 

For as long as I've been in college, neither myself nor anyone I have seen dresses like that/looks like they're enjoying themselves that much at college

For as long as I've been in college, neither myself nor anyone I have seen dresses like that/looks like they're enjoying themselves that much at college

May I ask what college you attended?

Mood/theme: 2 - i like the idea but between the music and editing i'm getting too much of a boogie nights vibe from this commercial and i feel like that should be the last thing i associate with collegiate attire...

Music: 1 - see above

Visual elements: 2.75 - i enjoy the retro concepts but once again see above

Effectiveness: 1.5 - da f*ck are they selling? what?

Likability: 2.5

+1